European Round-Table on Patent Practice (EUROTAB)
|European Case Law Identifier:||ECLI:EP:BA:2014:T044812.20140221|
|Date of decision:||21 February 2014|
|Case number:||T 0448/12|
|IPC class:||B65D 65/46|
|Language of proceedings:||EN|
|Download and more information:||
|Title of application:||WATER SOLUBLE CONTAINER|
|Applicant name:||Obrist Closures Switzerland GmbH|
|Opponent name:||The Procter & Gamble Company|
|Relevant legal provisions:||
|Keywords:||Basis of decision - revocation of the patent at request of the patent proprietor|
Summary of Facts and Submissions
I. The appellant (opponent) lodged an appeal against the interlocutory decision of the Opposition Division maintaining European patent No. 1 663 809 in amended form. It requested that the decision under appeal be set aside and the patent be revoked in its entirety. Oral proceedings were requested as an auxiliary measure.
II. The respondent (patent proprietor) requested at this stage that the decision of the opposition division be upheld, i.e. the dismissal of the appeal, and subsidiarily the maintenance of the patent on the basis of one of the sets of claims filed as first to sixth auxiliary requests. Oral proceedings were requested as an auxiliary measure.
III. With its communication dated 29 October 2013 the Board notified the parties that according to the information available to the European Patent Office the European Patent No. 1 663 809 had lapsed with effect for all the designated Contracting States. The respondent was requested to confirm within two months from notification of the communication that this was the case. Both parties were informed that if the European patent in question had lapsed in all designated Contracting States the appeal proceedings might be continued at the request of the appellant, provided that within two months from notification of the Boards communication a corresponding request were filed.
IV. With its letter dated 13 November 2013 the respondent confirmed that the contested patent has lapsed with effect for all the designated Contracting States and that it did not wish to continue with the appeal proceedings.
V. With its letter dated 12 December 2013 the appellant expressed its wish to continue with the appeal proceedings.
VI. With its summons dated 24 January 2014 the Board summoned the parties to oral proceedings.
VII. With its letter dated 18 February 2014 the respondent stated the following:
The Proprietor hereby confirms that it no longer approves the text intended for grant"
"[w]e request confirmation that the patent is revoked in its entirety and that the Appeal proceedings are closed.
VIII. On 20 February 2014, the Board cancelled the oral proceedings.
Reasons for the Decision
1. Article 113(2) EPC requires that the EPO may decide upon the European patent only in the text submitted to it, or agreed, by the proprietor of the patent.
2. Agreement cannot be held to be given if the proprietor without submitting an amended text, expressly states that he no longer approves the text of the patent as granted or as previously amended.
3. In the present case the respondent no longer approves the text intended for grant and requests confirmation that the patent is revoked in its entirety, see point VII above.
The Board considers the expression that it no longer approves the text intended for grant to mean that the respondent no longer approves the text of the patent as it was intended with the impugned decision for maintenance of the patent.
The Board considers the request for confirmation of the revocation to mean that the respondent also withdraws its auxiliary requests previously filed and will not submit any other requests.
4. In such a situation a substantive requirement for maintaining the patent is lacking and the proceedings are to be terminated by a decision ordering revocation, without going into the substantive issues (see e.g. decisions T 73/84, OJ EPO 1985, 241 and T 186/84, OJ EPO 1986, 79, reasons point 5).
For these reasons it is decided that:
1. The decision under appeal is set aside.
2. The patent is revoked