Quick Navigation

 

Case Law of the Boards of Appeal

 
 
O
Objections in accordance with Rule 106 EPC - petition for review, IV.E.9.2.5
Obligation 
~ of the EPO to examine of its own motion and prior use, I.C.1.9.9.c
~ to attend oral proceedings, III.C.1.1.3
~ to draw attention to easily remediable deficiencies, III.A.3, III.A.3.3
Electronic filing of documents, III.A.3.2.3
Fee payments, III.A.3.2.2
Party's own responsibility, III.A.3.3.1
~ to enquire in case of unclear nature of request, III.A.4
~ to give notice - non-attendance at oral proceedings, III.C.3.3
~ to maintain secrecy, I.C.1.9.8
Commercial agreements, I.C.1.9.8.g
Conferences, I.C.1.9.8.f
Making available for test purposes, I.C.1.9.8.e
Product in writing, I.C.1.9.8.d
Products for presentation purposes, I.C.1.9.8.c
Prospectuses, I.C.1.9.8.a
Observations 
~ by third parties, III.N
Anonymously filed ~, III.N.1.4
Fresh ground for opposition in appeal proceedings, III.N.3.3
Fresh ground for opposition in opposition proceedings, III.N.3.2
Language and ~, III.N.1.1
Legal status, III.N.2
Obvious alternatives - inventive step, I.D.9.18.9
Obvious new use - inventive step, I.D.9.12
Offer to submit evidence and right to be heard, III.B.1.3.2
Old prior art documents as closest prior art, I.D.3.6
Omitted act and re-establishment of rights, III.E.3.3
One-part or two-part claims, II.A.2.1.1
One-year time limit and re-establishment of rights, III.E.3.1.2
Opponent 
~ - re-establishment of rights, III.E.1.1
~ and transfer of party status, IV.C.2.2
Business assets, IV.C.2.2.3
Correct party as to transfer of party status, IV.C.2.2.5
Evidence for transfer of party status, IV.C.2.2.6
Universal succession, IV.C.2.2.2
~ as sole appellant and reformatio in peius, IV.E.3.1.f
Opportunity to 
~ present comments in opposition procedure, IV.D.5.4.5
~ reply in opposition procedure, IV.D.5.4.4
~ respond to summons and right to be heard, III.B.1.3.4
Opposition 
~ after surrender or lapse of the patent, IV.C.6.5
~ and language privilege, III.F.5.3
~ division - composition, III.K.2.2
~ divisions' exercise of discretion and late submission, IV.C.1.3.3
~ fee, IV.D.2.2.4
~ procedure, IV.D
Admissibility of opposition, IV.D.2
Amendments in opposition, IV.D.4
Contentious inter partes proceedings, IV.D.1.2
Decisions of the opposition division, IV.D.7
Entitlement to file an opposition, IV.D.2.1
Fresh facts and evidence, IV.D.5.3.5
Identity of the opponent, IV.D.2.2.2
Infringement proceedings pending - acceleration of proceedings, IV.D.6
Interlocutory decisions, IV.D.7.2
Invitation to file observations in ~, IV.D.5.4.2
Legal character of opposition proceedings, IV.D.1
Opportunity to present comments, IV.D.5.4.5
Opportunity to reply, IV.D.5.4.4
Principle of equal treatment, IV.D.5.4.1
Prior use alleged in ~, IV.D.3.3.3
Requests, III.I.6
Scope of examination in the case of amendments, IV.D.4.5
Straw man, IV.D.2.1.3
Substantiation of opposition, IV.D.3
Substantive examination of the opposition, IV.D.5
Title of the invention, IV.D.2.2.3
~ proceedings - unity of invention, II.B.3.4
Optimisation of parameters - inventive step, I.D.9.15
Oral 
~ proceedings, III.C
Absence of duly represented party - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.h
Adjournment of ~ and late submission, IV.C.1.4.2
Amended claims after arrangement of the ~, IV.E.4.2.2
Amended claims filed during the ~, IV.E.4.2.3
Amended claims without amended description, III.C.3.2
Apportionment of costs, III.C.5.1
Auxiliary request for ~, III.C.2.5
Booked holidays - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.b
Business engagements - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.d
Communication under Article 15(1) RPBA, III.C.4.3
Computer-generated presentations, III.C.4.7
Conference - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.c
Continuation of ~ on the next day, III.C.4.1.8
Correction of minutes, III.C.4.8.3
Costs, III.C.5
Excluding the public, III.C.4.12
Further ~ before the same department, III.C.2.4
Illness - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.a
Interpreting, III.C.4.10
Late submission of new facts and evidence during ~, III.C.4.4
Location of ~, III.C.4.5
Minutes of ~, III.C.4.8
National holiday - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.e
New arguments, III.B.2.1.3
New claims in ~ and right to be heard, III.B.2.1.1
New documents in ~ and right to be heard, III.B.2.1
Non-attendance at ~, III.C.3
Non-attendance at ~ - amended claims without amended description, III.C.3.2
Non-attendance at ~ - obligation to give notice, III.C.3.3
Notice of two months in the summons to ~, III.C.4.2
Obligation to attend ~, III.C.1.1.3
~ and equity of a different apportionment of costs, IV.C.7.2.2
~ before the Receiving Section, III.C.1.2
~ conducted by video conference, III.C.4.6
~ in further prosecution proceedings, III.C.2.7
Postponement of ~, III.C.4.1
Preparation and conduct of ~, III.C.4
Proceedings before a national court - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.6
Reimbursement of appeal fees, IV.E.8.3.2
Representative - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.3.f
Request for ~, III.C.2
Right to be heard in case of changes after ~, III.B.2.2
Right to be heard in case of the non-attendance at ~, III.B.2.3
Right to be heard in ~, III.B.2
Right to ~, III.C.1
Right to ~ after a communication in examination procedure, III.C.1.1.2.a
Right to present comments and non-attendance at ~, III.C.3.1
Speaking time during ~, III.C.4.9
Substitution of representative - postponement of ~, III.C.4.1.4
Unavailability of party at ~, III.C.4.1.3
Withdrawal of request for ~, III.C.2.3
Wording of request for ~, III.C.2.2
~ submissions by an accompanying person, III.R.5
Oral submissions by former members of the boards of appeal, III.R.5.2
Oral submissions by qualified patent lawyers of non-EPC contracting states, III.R.5.3
~ submissions in languages other than the language of proceedings, III.B.1.3.10
Order of requests, III.I.1
Ordre public, I.B.2, I.B.2.2.2.b
Breaches of ~ or morality, I.B.2
Morality, I.B.2.2.2.b
Organisational upheaval and re-establishment of rights, III.E.4.3.1
Overlapping ranges, I.C.5.2.2