G 0009/92 (Non-appealing party) vom 14.07.1994

Europäischer Rechtsprechungsidentifikator

ECLI:EP:BA:1994:G000992.19940714

Datum der Entscheidung

14. Juli 1994

Aktenzeichen

G 0009/92

Antrag auf Überprüfung von

T 0060/91 1992-10-05

Anmeldenummer

86111866.9

IPC-Klasse

B62D 65/00

Verfahrenssprache

Deutsch

Verteilung

Im Amtsblatt des EPA veröffentlicht (A)

Download

Amtsblattfassungen

Weitere Entscheidungen für diese Akte

G 0009/92 reformatio in peius 1993-06-22

Zusammenfassungen für diese Entscheidung

Bezeichnung der Anmeldung

Verfahren zum Abdecken von Öffnungen auf einem Hohlkörper durch dünnwandige, flächenhafte Gebilde

Name des Antragstellers

Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft

Name des Einsprechenden

KUKA Schweißanlagen + Roboter GmbH

Kammer

Leitsatz

1. If the patent proprietor is the sole appellant against an interlocutory decision maintaining a patent in amended form, neither the Board of Appeal nor the non-appealing opponent as a party to the proceedings as of right under Article 107, second sentence, EPC, may challenge the maintenance of the patent as amended in accordance with the interlocutory decision.

2.If the opponent is the sole appellant against an interlocutory decision maintaining a patent in amended form, the patent proprietor is primarily restricted during the appeal proceedings to defending the patent in the form in which it was maintained by the Opposition Division in its interlocutory decision. Amendments proposed by the patent proprietor as a party to the proceedings as of right under Article 107, second sentence, EPC, may be rejected as inadmissible by the Board of Appeal if they are neither appropriate nor necessary.

Relevante Rechtsnormen

European Patent Convention Art 101(2) 1973 European Patent Convention Art 107 1973 European Patent Convention Art 111 1973 European Patent Convention Art 114(1) 1973 European Patent Convention R 58(2) 1973 European Patent Convention R 64(b) 1973 European Patent Convention R 65(1) 1973 European Patent Convention R 66(1) 1973

Schlagwörter

Reformatio in peius
Patent maintained in amended form in accordance with auxiliary request
Opposing parties each adversely affected
Appeal by one party
Requests by a non-appealing party which go beyond the appellant's requests in the notice of appeal
Minority opinion

Orientierungssatz

Zitierte Akten

G 0002/91 G 0007/91 G 0008/91 G 0009/91 G 0010/91 T 0123/85 T 0576/89 T 0369/91 T 0096/92

Zitierende Akten

G 0010/93 G 0001/99 G 0003/04 G 0002/12 G 0002/13 G 0003/19 G 0002/24 R 0016/09 T 0060/91 T 0369/91 T 0488/91 T 0646/91 T 0716/91 T 0813/91 T 0898/91 T 0266/92 T 0501/92 T 0634/92 T 0856/92 T 0923/92 T 0933/92 T 0958/92 T 0169/93 T 0233/93 T 0321/93 T 0329/93 T 0528/93 T 0752/93 T 0829/93 T 1082/93 T 0233/94 T 0323/94 T 0414/94 T 0426/94 T 0437/94 T 0552/94 T 0562/94 T 0579/94 T 0812/94 T 0815/94 T 0900/94 T 0080/95 T 0277/95 T 0379/95 T 0389/95 T 0500/95 T 1002/95 T 0239/96 T 0275/96 T 0331/96 T 0336/96 T 0637/96 T 0762/96 T 0893/96 T 1011/96 T 0029/97 T 0063/97 T 0174/97 T 0315/97 T 0414/97 T 0522/97 T 0565/97 T 0701/97 T 0743/97 T 0108/98 T 0226/98 T 0339/98 T 0368/98 T 0386/98 T 0467/98 T 0473/98 T 0554/98 T 0590/98 T 0670/98 T 0750/98 T 1026/98 T 0080/99 T 0224/99 T 0268/99 T 0290/99 T 0304/99 T 0359/99 T 0399/99 T 0492/99 T 0598/99 T 0602/99 T 0636/99 T 0668/99 T 0717/99 T 0724/99 T 0898/99 T 0903/99 T 0966/99 T 1070/99 T 1099/99 T 0182/00 T 0204/00 T 0222/00 T 0706/00 T 0731/00 T 0782/00 T 0827/00 T 0886/00 T 0959/00 T 0968/00 T 0982/00 T 1072/00 T 1126/00 T 1143/00 T 0092/01 T 0120/01 T 0281/01 T 0318/01 T 0477/01 T 0764/01 T 0999/01 T 1004/01 T 1098/01 T 0609/02 T 0809/02 T 0864/02 T 0903/02 T 0937/02 T 1074/02 T 1108/02 T 0498/03 T 0520/03 T 0656/03 T 0724/03 T 0731/03 T 0794/03 T 1239/03 T 0023/04 T 0099/04 T 0168/04 T 0191/04 T 0386/04 T 0604/04 T 0676/04 T 1018/04 T 1178/04 T 1214/04 T 1316/04 T 1317/04 T 0127/05 T 0263/05 T 0319/05 T 0382/05 T 0405/05 T 0458/05 T 0950/05 T 1277/05 T 1393/05 T 1511/05 T 0032/06 T 0073/06 T 0181/06 T 0224/06 T 0332/06 T 0483/06 T 0558/06 T 0642/06 T 1009/06 T 1042/06 T 1207/06 T 1300/06 T 1455/06 T 1496/06 T 1747/06 T 0079/07 T 0152/07 T 0429/07 T 0521/07 T 0525/07 T 0535/07 T 0656/07 T 0659/07 T 0832/07 T 0949/07 T 0963/07 T 0982/07 T 1115/07 T 1205/07 T 1544/07 T 1556/07 T 1618/07 T 1774/07 T 0191/08 T 0356/08 T 0358/08 T 0384/08 T 0744/08 T 0889/08 T 1033/08 T 1082/08 T 1542/08 T 1713/08 T 2344/08 T 0150/09 T 0197/09 T 0209/09 T 0689/09 T 1224/09 T 1392/09 T 1464/09 T 1843/09 T 2311/09 T 0028/10 T 0095/10 T 0111/10 T 0216/10 T 0365/10 T 0427/10 T 0665/10 T 0722/10 T 0727/10 T 0974/10 T 1222/10 T 1267/10 T 1340/10 T 1367/10 T 1474/10 T 1499/10 T 1525/10 T 1649/10 T 1684/10 T 1866/10 T 0484/11 T 1157/11 T 1226/11 T 1400/11 T 1626/11 T 1782/11 T 2129/11 T 2538/11 T 0242/12 T 0251/12 T 0395/12 T 0416/12 T 0428/12 T 0470/12 T 0502/12 T 0576/12 T 0861/12 T 0910/12 T 1521/12 T 1689/12 T 2314/12 T 0009/13 T 0027/13 T 0115/13 T 0251/13 T 0711/13 T 0813/13 T 1486/13 T 1553/13 T 1626/13 T 2279/13 T 0589/14 T 0633/14 T 0700/14 T 1151/14 T 0210/15 T 0445/15 T 0611/15 T 1057/15 T 1103/15 T 1297/15 T 1729/15 T 1908/15 T 2366/15 T 0097/16 T 0185/16 T 0201/16 T 0422/16 T 0590/16 T 1797/16 T 1845/16 T 1875/16 T 2197/16 T 2472/16 T 0154/17 T 0184/17 T 0803/17 T 0811/17 T 0882/17 T 1071/17 T 1208/17 T 1254/17 T 1332/17 T 1336/17 T 1441/17 T 1561/17 T 1628/17 T 1653/17 T 1656/17 T 2056/17 T 2134/17 T 2533/17 T 2743/17 T 1051/18 T 1287/18 T 1536/18 T 1683/18 T 1770/18 T 1919/18 T 2212/18 T 2242/18 T 2277/18 T 2503/18 T 2654/18 T 2952/18 T 2954/18 T 0072/19 T 0225/19 T 0582/19 T 0683/19 T 0749/19 T 0835/19 T 1080/19 T 1266/19 T 1391/19 T 1577/19 T 2193/19 T 2229/19 T 2396/19 T 2408/19 T 2582/19 T 2771/19 T 3201/19 T 3214/19 T 3227/19 T 0204/20 T 0399/20 T 0624/20 T 0779/20 T 0905/20 T 1256/20 T 1508/20 T 1985/20 T 0345/21 T 0650/21 T 1419/21 T 1472/21 T 1788/21 T 1888/21 T 0298/22 T 0325/22 T 0327/22 T 1106/22 T 1175/22 T 1332/22 T 1340/22 T 1676/22 T 1695/22 T 1789/22 T 1824/22 T 2217/22 T 2421/22 T 2546/22 T 0330/23 T 0517/23 T 0724/23 T 1285/23 T 1286/23 T 1546/23 T 1547/23 T 1671/23 T 1936/23 T 1999/23

ORDER

For these reasons the two-part point of law referred to the Enlarged Board of Appeal is answered as follows:

2. If the opponent is the sole appellant against an interlocutory decision maintaining a patent in amended form, the patent proprietor is primarily restricted during appeal proceedings to defending the patent in the form in which it was maintained by the Opposition Division in its interlocutory decision. Amendments proposed by the patent proprietor as a party to the proceedings as of right under Article 107, second sentence, EPC, may be rejected as inadmissible by the Board of Appeal if they are neither appropriate nor necessary.